Goodfella's Pizzeria

Discover delicious pizza at Goodfella's Pizzeria in Miami, OK. Enjoy affordable prices, gluten-free options, calzones, flavorful ranch, killer bacon, and fun game and pinball machine. Perfect for road trips and casual dining!

Welcome to Goodfella's Pizzeria

Experience the finest dining

Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria

Goodfella's Pizzeria stands out on N Main St in Miami, Oklahoma. This spot draws locals and visitors alike with its vibrant atmosphere and delicious offerings. As you step inside, the enticing aroma of fresh pizza greets you, immediately making you feel at home. Whether you're a fan of classic slices or adventurous flavors, Goodfella's offers something for everyone. The menu ranges from large pizzas like 'The Corleone' to gluten-free options. Enjoy a game of pinball before or after your meal to complete your journey into pizza paradise.

Stop by for a slice, or two, and experience why this place has become a community favorite. With local flair and comfort food, Goodfella's Pizzeria promises to satisfy your cravings.

Goodfella's Pizzeria brings an impressive selection of hearty, flavorful pizzas perfect for any occasion. The restaurant's menu includes large, medium, and small pizzas alongside their well-renowned calzones. Highlights include classics like 'The Boss' and specialty pizzas such as the 'Bacon Cheeseburger With Mustard & Pickles'. Beyond pizza, patrons can enjoy various dipping sauces, pastas, salads, and decadent desserts, including a giant chocolate chip cookie. Pricing remains accessible, inviting families and friends to savor memorable moments together. Additionally, Goodfella's features dine-in options and takeout, making it easy to grab a meal on the go. With every bite, you'll appreciate the commitment to quality ingredients and generous portions, ensuring every visit feels worthwhile.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

34 N Main St, Miami, OK 74354, United States

Phone

+1 918-919-3803

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria
Goodfella's Pizzeria

Goodfella's Pizzeria offers more than just exceptional food; it provides a slice of local culture that resonates with the Miami community. Nestled at 34 N Main St, this pizza haven attracts a diverse crowd with its welcoming vibe and pocket-friendly prices. Many frequenters rave about the calzones, praising their indulgent flavor and satisfying size, making them a popular choice among the hungry.

The standout menu also caters to dietary preferences, ensuring gluten-free options are available, allowing everyone to enjoy a great meal without compromise.

As you explore the restaurant, the pinball machine often draws a crowd, creating a lively and entertaining atmosphere that sets the place apart from typical pizza joints. Goodfella's makes a conscious effort to weave local character and community spirit into their dining experience.

Regular events or themed nights foster a fun, energetic ambiance that keeps customers returning to soak up the good vibes.

When it comes to value, Goodfella's Pizzeria shines. With an average meal price of $14.91, diners enjoy a variety of dishes that do not break the bank. The extensive menu features 62 different items, ranging from appetizers to desserts. Patrons can expect delicious food without sacrificing quality or taste.

Goodfella's continues to evolve, listening to community feedback and updating its offerings to match customer desires while retaining its signature style. Whether you're dining in or taking out, each meal brings a little joy to the table.

Goodfella's Pizzeria

The exterior of Goodfella's Pizzeria is inviting, with a classic pizzeria look that hints at the culinary delights within. Bright signage catches the eye, making it easy to locate amid the bustling Miami streets. The outdoor layout is equally charming, offering a cozy and laid-back vibe for those who prefer dining al fresco. Imagine enjoying a warm pizza on a sunny day, laughter filling the air as families and friends gather at nearby tables. This outdoor area enhances the community-focused atmosphere and allows for unique dining experiences that match the lively Oklahoma spirit.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday1-9 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Goodfella's Pizzeria located in the downtown area of Miami, OK on Route 66 offers a variety of pizza combinations as well as other Italian-styled cuisines. This is our favorite location to eat at when attending an event at the Coleman Theater as it is within walking distance. They do offer carry-out or even delivery options. On our most recent visit, we ordered a small, original crust, half pepperoni and half cheese pizza. It was delicious. We love being able to play the retro pinball machine while we wait. There are classic photographs hanging around the restaurant you can check-out as well that portray the downtown Miami area from the 1940's and they make great conversational pieces. When you visit, be sure to ask about the weekly specials!

T
Twyla K.

This pizza brought me back to a great childhood memory. When I took a bite OMG! I will definitely!!!! Be back when I go on vacation again. Love love live them. Wings are amazing also

J
Jenna L.

Stopped in for lunch with a friend at his recommendation. Absolutely loved the food. They have great lunch specials and a vintage Terminator 2 pinball machine as well as a game cabinet. My only complaint is they don't carry anchovies as a toping choice. If you're going through Miami, be sure to give this place a whirl.

J
Justin H.

The Pepperoni Pizza was really good with the thicker crust and lots of cheese. We got the bbq wings also with some ranch. They were great as well. We Ordered our food and it wasn't a long wait before we got it. Definitely will be going back again soon.

D
Deborah L.

I was only shortly visiting Miami, but stopped here during a walk, turned out to have amazing staff members, owner had amazing hospitality towards me and my partner. Food was above par for price, wings were huge and delicious and everything perfectly hot and made to order. Bathrooms clean too, couldn't find a single complaint if you tried.

R
Ryan

I first went before summer and the staff was very nice and my food was fresh and delicious! I love finding little places like this!

M
Marybeth W.